What Becomes of the Yogi Who Falls Short - Yoga Research Foundation

A study guide to Srimad Bhagavad Gita, Chapter Six, verses 37 to 42 — Lecture 74 by Swami Jyotirmayananda

Orientation

There is a fear that sits underneath any long practice, and in the closing verses of the sixth chapter Arjuna finally says it out loud. He does not ask about the person who never began, or the person who abandoned the path. He asks about the one who tried. Someone with faith, someone sincere, whose mind will not hold still — who dies before anything is attained. “One who is unable to control himself. Despite his faith. One whose mind wanders away from the state of yoga. Thus, failing to attain yogic perfection. What end does he meet, O Lord?” (12:37)

The question has teeth because it points at a genuine double loss. Such a person has given up the ordinary consolations of the world and has not arrived at the extraordinary ones. At 16:49 Swamiji puts the objection in its most uncomfortable form: there are people who have been very bright and who die at thirty, at twenty, at whatever age. “He has lost the pleasures of the world. And goal is not attained. Neither here nor there.” Then he stacks three further versions of the same fear — that a distressing life might terminate before the work is done and the whole edifice must be rebuilt in a new body (17:36); that illness or confusion might take the memory of practice altogether (19:00); and that dying itself is not a gentle process, so that “all the sādhana you have done and death demolishes all” (19:41).

This lecture is Krishna’s answer to that, and the answer is unconditional rather than consoling. Before he reaches it, Swamiji spends twelve minutes restating the three pillars the chapter has already established — repeated effort, the loosening of dependence on the world, and surrender — and reframing them so that the fear cannot get purchase in the first place. The reframe is the useful part for anyone actually practising: if each day is treated as the goal rather than as a payment toward some later success, there is no ledger left to be wiped out. The verses then describe what happens to the one who falls short, and the surprise is that there are two different outcomes, the rarer of which is the better one.

Passage index

Each timestamp opens the lecture at that moment.

A single cloud drawn apart by the wind above a still river valley at dawn.

Making each day the goal, not the payment

Arjuna’s earlier question — how can the mind be controlled when it works like an uncontrolled wind — had already received its answer: abhyāsa and vairāgya, repeated effort and the loosening of dependence. What Swamiji adds at 02:48 is that abhyāsa is not a mood but a plan. Start with japa and meditation, get insight into how they are actually done, add some yoga exercises, include satsaṅga, and let the whole of it be clear in the mind before you begin. His test for whether the plan is any good is unusual: it must be “harmonious, rhythmic, and delightful to your mind.” A plan that is merely correct will not survive contact with an ordinary week.

Then the line that does the real work at 03:33: “Make each of your day delicious. Don’t live with a sense that one day I will be going to be very happy because I’m practicing yoga. In 6 months I will get success. That each day is your goal.” This is the structural answer to the fear Arjuna is about to raise. A practice held as an investment can be wiped out by an early death; a practice held as its own completion cannot. The accounting changes.

At 04:01 he pairs this with a warning about temperament. The mind must have a mature way of looking at things rather than a childish way, because “if things don’t work out the way you want it, you are childish, you begin to cry and all the yoga explodes.” The maturity is not stoicism. It rests on a claim about how the moral universe is built: “Nothing good that you do can ever be wasted. Positive movement is the remedy for all that is negative.”

The image he uses to make this ordinary is food. Nobody eats a meal and then complains about how long they will have to go on eating, or when they will finally be free of minerals and vitamins. Eating brings no conflict because we do not expect it to be finished. “Why should love of God, prayer, japa, meditation, satsaṅga, listening to the glory of sages and saints — why should these bring any botheration to your mind?” (05:26)

The bird who has not grown wings

Vairāgya is the pillar most often mistranslated as coldness, so it is worth following how Swamiji actually describes its arrival at 06:11. It is not a decision to care less. It is what happens to dependence as practice continues: the supports we lean on — tastes, gross habits, the company we keep — begin to loosen their hold, and the loosening is not initially pleasant.

His picture of the middle stage is the most memorable thing in the lecture. You find yourself on a tree. “You are a bird, but somehow you have not grown your wings yet. And you are at the branch of a tree and everything is terrible for you. Even a squirrel comes and jumps up and down and you are threatened.” (06:54) This is precisely the condition of someone whose worldly supports have begun to fail while their inner strength has not yet arrived. The remedy is not to climb back down. “However, as wings develop, strengthens the soul.”

The definition follows at 07:34, and it is a definition by negation: “You are not supported by the world. That’s vairāgya.” Not that the world is bad, but that it need not always be there furnishing a field of enjoyment. He then argues that detachment is not even a strange demand, because we already practise it nightly. The best part of the day is sleep, and in sleep we are completely detached — “Ego that you loved so much, even that ego is thrown away. Time, space all move away.” (09:02) If the mind can release everything every night without complaint, the capacity is clearly there.

For those who find the ideal too remote, 09:59 offers the practical version: be a swimmer. You are in the world, and that is fine; the instruction is not to be devoured by it. “You are in the ocean. Don’t sink in it. Learn to swim.” And if even that seems impractical, he concedes the point and shrinks the requirement to almost nothing: sink in it, “but not let your nose go down.” Keep the buddhi, the discriminating intellect, above the surface. That is a floor low enough for anyone to stand on.

The third pillar arrives at 11:14 with its Raja Yoga formula, tapaḥ svādhyāya īśvarapraṇidhānāni — austerity, self-study, and surrender to God. Tapaḥ relates to physical discipline; svādhyāya covers japa and the study of scripture and satsaṅga, so that a deeper insight into one’s own Self is gained. Taken together with abhyāsa and vairāgya, Swamiji says, this becomes the mantra: the most powerful method of attaining liberation.

Four ways the fear presents itself

Having built the positive case, Swamiji lets the doubt have its full say, and the fairness of his treatment is what makes the passage useful. He gives the objection four distinct forms.

The first is arithmetic. “Suppose your karma is a big forest. How much of that forest can you clean up with all your effort?” (14:01) Set against lifetimes of accumulated karma, one lifetime of practice looks like clearing a few square feet, and the mind’s estimate of its own progress is unreliable anyway — “your mental mathematics is very poor.”

The second is interruption. Some people leave their sādhana because of saṃśaya, doubt. Others are stopped by illness. At 14:45 he names the threefold affliction, tritāpas: misery arising from the body, misery created by people and war and politics from outside, and misery coming from the heavens — what an insurance policy would call an act of God. His conclusion is flat: “no movement in the world is perfectly secured.”

The third is early death, already quoted, with its verdict of neither here nor there.

The fourth is the loss of the memory of practice itself, which is the subtlest of the four. Under exceeding distress the mind can be perplexed profoundly; memory can go (18:20). And dying is not easy — “Serious sorrows and sufferings are experienced by the mind.” Will the mind hold on to its memory of sādhana at the end, or does death demolish everything? At 19:41 he stops there deliberately: “I will not elaborate any further.”

Verses 38 and 39 give the doubt its final form, and Arjuna’s own image is the bleakest in the chapter. Fallen from both the path of karma and the path of jñāna, does such a person “not perish like a cloud that has been rent asunder by the wind? Without any support” (21:16). Then, in verse 39, the request: “This is my doubt, O Kṛṣṇa. Please rend it asunder. Because it’s not possible for anyone except You to dispel this doubt.”

Grace in four movements

Before Krishna answers, Swamiji pauses on the fact that Arjuna is now asking properly, and builds a small teaching out of it. Doubt, saṃśaya, is a real obstacle, and resolving it requires guidance from a source that inspires. But proximity alone is not enough — Arjuna had Krishna beside him constantly and remained under many illusions. “Even if you bring yourself to the most enlightened personality, in close conjunction, and yet the benefit you receive will depend upon how much you are qualified for.” You can be brought to a table of delicious dishes; how much you enjoy depends on your appetite (23:23).

The hunger itself is the first grace. When the inquiring heart develops — when the question of what the goal is and how it is reached becomes urgent from the inside — “That’s called ātmakṛpā. Your soul has become gracious to you.” (24:48) Swamiji grounds this in the chapter’s own instruction, uddhared ātmanātmānam: rescue the soul by your own soul. The soul has two aspects, higher and lower, and until now the lower has been the one doing the pushing.

From there the sequence unfolds: ātmakṛpā produces aspiration, which leads you to a guru, gurukṛpā; the guru initiates you into the scriptures, which is śāstrakṛpā. And here he notes something that anyone who has reread a familiar text under guidance will recognise. The same Gita, the same Ramayana, the same Upanishad you have read in libraries — “Now under guru’s guidance, Gītā, just few words of the Gītā. They become explosive. They gain a tremendous power.” (27:45) The books have not changed. “They are not just books.” All of these, he concludes, are aspects of īśvarakṛpā, God’s grace.

Nothing is ever lost

The reply arrives at 28:53 with no hedging in it. “O Arjuna. A Yogi is never destroyed. Neither in this world nor in the next. O friend, whoever does good does not tread the path of grief.”

Swamiji’s gloss narrows it to something testable. He is not talking about ordinary change but about transformation, and about that he says: “Whatever degree of change you have brought within yourself, it is never lost. Any positive step you have taken towards enriching yourself in a spiritual way, it is never lost.” (29:35) Note what this does to all four forms of the doubt at once. If the gain is a change in what you are rather than a balance accumulated somewhere, then a short life, a failed memory, an interrupted practice and a poorly estimated forest are all beside the point.

Why heaven is a dream you must wake from

Verse 41 then says the fallen yogi enjoys heavenly worlds for everlasting years and is afterward born in the house of the pure and prosperous — and Swamiji immediately flags the language as allegorical, on straightforward logical grounds: if the enjoyment were literally everlasting, nothing further could ever happen (30:58).

What svarga actually describes is intensity. Good karma produces prosperous situations during life; after death, without the body, the same karma produces enjoyment “million times greater than the intensity of enjoyment that you can have in the physical plane.” The reason is mechanical rather than mystical: “Physical body acts like a restrictive valve. If your happiness goes beyond certain, your body gets paralyzed. You can’t bear it.” (35:52) His domestic example is a lottery win — seventy million dollars arriving to someone who had little, and the elation you swim in for a while. That, he says, is a small taste of heaven, and the same valve governs pain, which is why beyond a certain degree of suffering a person simply passes out.

But intensity is not resolution. “Happiness that does not give you ultimate resolution to all your problems, but simply delays. It’s just like you have entered into a dream and dream has become so interesting. You don’t want to wake up. But no matter how interesting your dream, you have to wake up.” (33:41) Heaven, on this reading, is not a destination but a postponement — which is why the verse describes it as something the yogi passes through on the way to a birth.

Two rebirths, and the rarer one

The turn that decides which birth follows is the ego. While the sense of I is still leading, the movement is sakāmya — desire-bearing, within pravṛtti — and it accumulates good karma alongside negative karma, and its fruit is happiness rather than freedom. But good actions can, at some point, let you slip: “Slip for the best. Come to a state — let me not hold on to my ego. Let me turn to the higher power and say, what is best for me? Do that to me. A higher trust develops. He knows better than I know.” (32:24)

The one who dies before completing that turn is born, as verse 41 says, into a house that is pure and prosperous. Swamiji’s example is the Buddha: born into a royal family, given everything, and the very prosperity that makes ordinary people sink into worldliness instead moved him to ask how the misery of the world might end.

The one who has made the turn — who has, in Swamiji’s phrase, more than a sniff of the transcendent — receives the rarer birth of verse 42: athavā yoginām eva kule bhavati dhīmatām, in the family of wise yogis, a birth the verse itself calls most difficult to attain. Here the wealth is of a different kind. Śrīmatām, he points out, can be read through mati, understanding: a family whose richness is clarity and daivī sampat, the divine qualities. A child in such a house hears the scriptures from their parents, as Madalasa sang over her infant, śuddho’si buddho’si niranjano’si — you are pure, you are awake, you are untainted. Such a child may, like Nachiketa, be only a few years old and already arrive. Born there, he says, “you have no other choice but to become liberated.” And the liberation is less achieved than received: “You have inherited it.”

Srimad Bhagavad Gita, Chapter Six (Atmasanyam Yoga), verses 37 to 42. Lecture 74 by Swami Jyotirmayananda, Yoga Research Foundation.

The Foundation’s archive of Swamiji’s lectures is free to all.

Drawn from the archived teachings of Sri Swami Jyotirmayananda.